strategy+business is published by PwC Strategy& Inc.
 
or, sign in with:
strategy and business
Published: March 2, 2012

 
 

Best Time for a Takeover? When the Target’s CEO Turns 65

With less at risk personally, retirement-age CEOs may haggle less.

Title: CEO Preferences and Acquisitions

Authors: Dirk Jenter (Stanford University and National Bureau of Economic Research) and Katharina Lewellen (Dartmouth University)

Publisher: Rock Center for Corporate Governance at Stanford University, Working Paper No. 105

Date Published: December 2011

Thinking about making a run at a company? You might get a better deal if you wait until the target’s chief executive turns 65. That’s the conclusion of this paper, which finds that firms are more likely to receive takeover bids when the CEO reaches retirement age than when the CEO is younger — and they are more likely to accept those later bids at prices that are less than ideal to shareholders.

The CEO is at the heart of a firm’s decisions about mergers and acquisitions, and once a takeover bid is lodged, the authors note, the chief executive takes the lead in shaping the firm’s responses. The influence of a CEO’s age on those decisions, they found, has largely escaped scrutiny.

But because CEOs usually lose their jobs during or just after a takeover, and studies have shown that departing CEOs often don’t find a comparable job at a public firm, many departing CEOs are pushed into early retirement. Thus, a takeover can be costly for a CEO’s career, notwithstanding the fact that compensation contracts often contain golden parachutes and special bonuses for CEOs in case their firm is sold.

The authors hypothesized that career costs represent a potential conflict with shareholders’ interests, because CEOs may want to stave off a takeover even if the timing and price of the deal are quite favorable to the company. Conversely, these potential costs should become less important to CEOs as they conclude their careers, and that may then open the door to deals that are not optimal for shareholders.

To test the hypothesis, the authors analyzed whether CEO retirement age —typically 65 — affected the frequency, pricing, and outcomes of takeover bids.

Combining several U.S. databases and excluding interim CEOs, the authors collected data on 5,841 CEOs and nearly 1,000 takeover bids from 1992 through 2008. In a regression analysis, they found that the likelihood of a takeover bid increased sharply when the targeted CEO reached 65. After controlling for CEO and firm characteristics, the authors determined that the probability that a firm would be the target of a takeover bid was close to 4 percent per year for CEOs younger than the retirement age. However, the likelihood increased to 6 percent for the retirement-age group, or those 65 and older, representing a 50 percent increase in the odds of receiving a bid.

“The increase in takeover activity appears abruptly at the age-65 threshold, with no gradual increase as CEOs approach retirement age,” the authors write. “These results show that bidders are more likely to target firms with retirement-age CEOs, possibly due to these CEOs’ weaker expected resistance against takeover bids.”

The authors next examined the effect of decisions by retirement-age CEOs on how much their shareholders gained from selling off the company. The attitude of CEOs toward a takeover bid is shaped by several factors, the authors say: how much they stand to lose in terms of their career prospects, how much that loss might be offset by a golden parachute, and the overall impact on shareholder value — something that is always of interest to the board, which has the final say.

When CEOs reach retirement age and have less to lose in a takeover, they will settle for deals that result in smaller gains for shareholders, the authors found. Their evidence: Takeover premiums — the difference between the estimate of a target firm’s value before the deal and the actual purchase price — and stock increases related to the takeover announcement are significantly lower when CEOs are 65 or older.

 
 
 
Follow Us 
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google Plus YouTube RSS strategy+business Digital and Mobile products App Store